March 16 • Cultural Insight
Freedom of Information Day
The war on secrets. This is a debate on transparency vs. security. We explore the 1751 birthday of James Madison and the modern battle over state secrets. When is the truth dangerous, and when is secrecy a crime against the people?
Speaking Discussion
- Should the government have ANY secrets from its citizens? Who decides what is dangerous to know?
- Is whistleblowing (like Snowden or Assange) an act of patriotism or an act of treason?
- Does too much information make society more chaotic, or more stable?
- Should we have a right to be forgotten online—to delete our past mistakes from the internet forever?
- If you could have the master password to one government's secret files for one hour, which country would you choose?
Activity 1: The Transparency Trial
The Task: You are a judge. A journalist wants to publish files showing the government lied about a war. The government says this will put soldiers in danger. You have 3 minutes to balance the rights. Write your verdict.
Activity 2: Rapid Fire Debate
Rapid fire justification: 1. 'Privacy is dead, and we killed it for convenience.' 2. 'Lying is a necessary tool for a successful government.' 3. 'A person who has nothing to hide should have nothing to fear.'
NATIVEUK.COM LESSONS